Can You Leave Carpet Padding Under Vinyl Plank Flooring?

You’ve just ripped out that old carpet, and you’re ready for a fresh look with vinyl plank flooring. But what about the carpet padding underneath? Should you leave it or remove it? It’s a common question with seemingly straightforward answers, but there’s more to it than meets the eye. While it might seem tempting to save time and effort by leaving the padding, there are some crucial factors to consider before making your decision.

Image: www.diychatroom.com

Vinyl plank flooring has become increasingly popular for its durability, affordability, and easy maintenance. This versatile flooring option can be installed over various subfloors, but whether you can keep the old carpet padding underneath is a question with a nuanced answer. The key lies in understanding the properties of both vinyl plank flooring and carpet padding and how they interact under certain conditions.

Understanding Vinyl Plank Flooring and Its Installation

Vinyl plank flooring is a type of floating floor, meaning it’s not directly attached to the subfloor. Instead, it relies on an underlayment or padding for support and cushioning. This allows for expansion and contraction due to temperature fluctuations without creating gaps or buckling. Vinyl planks come in various designs, mimicking the look of wood, tile, or stone, making them a popular choice for both modern and traditional decor.

Types of Vinyl Plank Flooring

Knowing the type of vinyl plank flooring you’re using is essential. The two most common types are:

• Luxury vinyl plank (LVP): This type is thicker and typically more durable than traditional vinyl plank. It can withstand heavier foot traffic and even furniture placement.
• Luxury vinyl tile (LVT): While similar to LVP, LVT is usually thinner and more flexible. It’s often preferred for applications where a thinner floor is desired, such as over existing tile or concrete.

The Importance of Underlayment

Underlayment is a crucial component for vinyl plank flooring, providing several benefits:

• Sound absorption: Reduces noise transmission between floors, making it a good choice for apartment living or multi-level homes.
• Comfort and impact absorption: Creates a more comfortable walking surface, reducing strain on joints.
• Moisture barrier: Some underlayments offer moisture resistance, protecting your subfloor and flooring from water damage.
• Surface leveling: Corrects minor imperfections in the subfloor, ensuring a smoother and more stable installation.

Image: dragon-upd.com

Assessing Carpet Padding: A Potential Problem

Now let’s delve into the potential issues with leaving carpet padding under your vinyl plank flooring. While carpet padding offers some benefits, it can also introduce challenges for your new flooring:

1. Moisture and Mold Risk

Carpet padding is often made from materials like foam or felt, which are prone to absorbing moisture. If the subfloor is damp or you encounter a leak, the padding can trap moisture, creating a breeding ground for mold and mildew. This can lead to unpleasant odors and potential health concerns, damaging your subfloor and vinyl planks.

2. Compression and Uneven Surface

Over time, carpet padding can compress and lose its springiness, especially under heavy furniture. This uneven surface can become noticeable under vinyl plank flooring, causing unlevel areas and potential buckling or cracking of the planks.

3. Unstable Base

The softness of carpet padding can create a less stable base for your vinyl planks, making them susceptible to movement and shifting. This can lead to squeaking or clicking sounds as you walk on the floor, detracting from the overall performance and quality of your installation.

Considerations for Leaving Carpet Padding: Evaluating Your Situation

While the risks of leaving carpet padding under vinyl plank flooring are significant, there are a few situations where it might be acceptable:

1. New and High-Quality Carpet Padding

If the existing padding is relatively new, made of high-quality materials that are moisture-resistant and robust, and the subfloor is dry and level, you might be able to keep it. However, it’s crucial to assess its condition thoroughly and consider the potential risks.

2. Thin and Dense Padding

Thin and dense padding, like those used with carpet tiles, might be suitable for vinyl plank installations. The key is to ensure it’s not too soft and won’t compress over time, creating an uneven surface.

3. Professional Assessment and Approval

It’s always wise to seek professional advice from a flooring specialist or contractor before making a decision. They can assess your subfloor, carpet padding, and the type of vinyl plank flooring you choose to determine if it’s safe and appropriate to leave the padding.

Alternatives to Carpet Padding: Seeking a Safer Solution

If you’re concerned about the potential risks associated with carpet padding, there are several alternative solutions you can consider:

1. Vinyl Plank Flooring Underlayment

Specialized underlayment made specifically for vinyl plank flooring is a popular choice. These underlayments are designed with various features like moisture resistance, soundproofing, and even surface leveling. They come in rolls or tiles and are relatively easy to install.

2. Foam Underlayment

Foam underlayment is a versatile and commonly used option for vinyl plank flooring. It offers cushioning, sound absorption, and a level surface for your planks. However, it’s crucial to select the right type of foam underlayment, as some can be susceptible to moisture and compression.

3. Cork Underlayment

Cork is a natural and sustainable option for vinyl plank underlayment. It provides excellent sound absorption, cushioning, and even moisture resistance. Cork is also known for its durability and long-lasting performance.

Can You Leave Carpet Padding Under Vinyl Plank Flooring

https://youtube.com/watch?v=j8qY8fuMLPw

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Project

Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to leave carpet padding under your vinyl plank flooring depends on various factors, including the condition of the padding, the type of flooring you’re using, and the overall moisture levels in your home. It’s essential to weigh the risks and benefits and make an informed decision based on your specific circumstances. Always consult with a professional to get expert advice on the best approach for your project. By considering all the factors and taking necessary precautions, you can achieve a successful vinyl plank installation and enjoy a stunning and durable new floor for years to come.