Should You Put Underlayment Under Vinyl Plank Flooring?

You’ve finally chosen the perfect vinyl plank flooring for your home, but now you’re faced with a decision: is underlayment necessary? It’s a common question, and one that often sparks debate among DIY enthusiasts and flooring professionals. After all, underlayment adds an extra layer to your flooring installation, potentially increasing costs and complexity. But is it truly essential, or can you safely skip it?

Image: www.kyinbridges.com

The answer, like most things in the world of home improvement, is not as straightforward as a simple “yes” or “no.” Underlayment serves a variety of purposes, and its necessity depends on factors like your existing subfloor, the type of vinyl planks you’ve chosen, and your desired level of comfort and sound insulation.

The Advantages of Underlayment

Underlayment isn’t just an added expense for the sake of it. It offers several distinct advantages that can greatly enhance your flooring experience. These benefits extend from basic protection to improved comfort, sound insulation, and even the lifespan of your vinyl planks.

1. Subfloor Protection and Leveling

Vinyl plank flooring is known for its durability, but it’s still susceptible to damage from uneven subfloors. Underlayment acts as a buffer, absorbing minor imperfections and providing a smooth surface for your planks to rest upon. This crucial protection helps prevent warping, cracking, and premature wear and tear on your flooring.

2. Enhanced Comfort and Noise Reduction

Walking on a bare subfloor can feel hard and unforgiving, especially if you have a concrete foundation. Underlayment adds a layer of cushioning, making your floor feel softer and more comfortable underfoot. It also significantly reduces noise transmission from foot traffic, minimizing the sound of footsteps and making your home feel quieter and more peaceful.

Image: www.dreamstime.com

3. Improved Insulation and Energy Efficiency

Underlayment can help enhance your home’s energy efficiency by adding a layer of insulation between your flooring and the subfloor. This acts as a barrier against drafts, reducing heat loss in the winter and keeping your home cooler in the summer. While this benefit might be less significant than dedicated insulation, every little bit can help improve your home’s thermal performance.

4. Noise Reduction for Above-Ground Floors

Living in an apartment or above another dwelling presents unique challenges for noise control. Underlayment can dramatically reduce the transmission of sound from your flooring to floors below. This is especially important for vinyl plank flooring, which tends to be more inherently “noisy” than thicker carpets or hardwood floors.

Types of Underlayment

Underlayment isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution. Various types are available, each with its distinct characteristics and benefits. Understanding these differences can help you choose the best underlayment for your specific needs.

1. Foam Underlayment

Foam underlayment is the most popular type, offering a cost-effective and versatile solution for many flooring projects. It’s available in various thicknesses and densities, catering to different needs regarding noise reduction, cushioning, and insulation. Foam underlayment is generally easy to install and lightweight, making it a good choice for DIY projects.

2. Cork Underlayment

Cork underlayment is a natural and sustainable option that provides excellent comfort, sound insulation, and a touch of elegance. It’s known for its springy texture, offering superior cushioning and noise reduction compared to foam. However, cork underlayment is typically more expensive than foam and may require a more skilled installation.

3. Rubber Underlayment

Rubber underlayment is a durable and highly effective option for sound dampening and moisture resistance. It is often used in commercial settings but is also becoming popular for residential applications, especially in areas prone to moisture issues. Rubber underlayment is typically thicker than foam and can significantly reduce impact noise.

When Underlayment is Necessary

While underlayment offers benefits, it’s not always a necessity. Consider whether your project aligns with these scenarios to make an informed decision:

1. Uneven Subfloors

If your subfloor has noticeable imperfections or unevenness, underlayment is crucial to create a level surface for your vinyl planks. Failing to do so can lead to warping, cracking, and premature wear and tear on your flooring.

2. Concrete Subfloors

Concrete subfloors are notorious for being cold and echoing. Underlayment adds a layer of insulation and sound dampening, providing greater comfort and reducing noise transmission.

3. Thin or Unstable Subfloors

If your subfloor is thin or lacking stability, underlayment can provide extra support and prevent your vinyl planks from sagging or buckling over time.

4. Above-Ground Floors

For floors above other dwellings, underlayment is essential for noise reduction to avoid disturbing those below. It can significantly reduce impact noise caused by foot traffic and other activities on your floor.

When You Can Skip Underlayment

While underlayment offers many advantages, some situations allow you to skip it without compromising the durability or performance of your vinyl plank flooring.

1. Already Smooth and Level Subfloors

If your subfloor is already smooth, level, and stable, underlayment may be unnecessary. However, consult with a flooring professional to ensure your subfloor meets the required standards for direct installation.

2. You’re On a Tight Budget

Underlayment can add significantly to your overall flooring installation costs. If you’re on a tight budget, you may be able to skip underlayment, especially if your subfloor is in excellent condition. However, be aware that this could compromise certain benefits like comfort and noise reduction.

3. You’re Using Glued Flooring

Some types of vinyl plank flooring are designed for glued installation. In these cases, underlayment is often unnecessary as the adhesive creates a tight bond and eliminates the need for additional cushioning or support.

Choosing the Right Underlayment

With so many types of underlayment available, choosing the right one can seem overwhelming. Consider these factors to make an informed decision:

1. Your Budget

Foam underlayment is generally the most affordable option, while cork and rubber underlayment can be more expensive. Set a budget and narrow your choices based on what fits your financial constraints.

2. Your Needs and Priorities

Do you prioritize noise reduction, comfort, or insulation? Different underlayment types excel in different areas. Choose the type that best aligns with your needs and priorities.

3. Your Subfloor

The condition of your subfloor is essential when selecting underlayment. If your subfloor has imperfections, you’ll need a thicker or more resilient underlayment to compensate. Conversely, a smooth and level subfloor might allow for a thinner and less expensive option.

4. Your Vinyl Plank Flooring Type

Some vinyl plank flooring options are designed for direct installation without underlayment. If you’re using this type of flooring, you can skip underlayment altogether. However, always check the manufacturer’s instructions for specific guidelines.

Should You Put Underlayment Under Vinyl Plank Flooring

Conclusion

Ultimately, the decision of whether to use underlayment under vinyl plank flooring is a personal one. Weighing the pros and cons, considering your budget, and evaluating the condition of your subfloor will help make the best choice for your specific situation. Underlayment can significantly enhance your flooring experience, providing extra comfort, noise reduction, and protection for your investment. But if your subfloor is already in good condition and you’re on a tight budget, you may be able to skip underlayment without compromising the quality of your installation.

Remember, consulting a flooring professional can provide invaluable expertise and help you make an informed decision that best suits your needs. And don’t forget to factor in the long-term benefits of underlayment, ensuring a more comfortable, enjoyable, and durable flooring experience for years to come!