Choosing the Right Thickness – 5/8 vs 3/4 Engineered Hardwood Flooring

The decision to install hardwood flooring is a significant one, bringing with it the promise of warmth, elegance, and increased property value. But amidst the myriad choices, one crucial consideration often arises: what thickness of engineered hardwood is best? This seemingly simple question can spark a debate among builders, remodelers, and homeowners alike. While 3/4-inch engineered hardwood has traditionally reigned as the standard, 5/8-inch options are gaining popularity, each offering a unique set of advantages and disadvantages.

Image: theroomdesigns.blogspot.com

In this comprehensive guide, we aim to shed light on the nuances of both 5/8-inch and 3/4-inch engineered hardwood flooring, exploring their respective strengths and weaknesses to help you make an informed decision. Whether you’re embarking on a new construction project or planning a meticulous renovation, understanding the implications of each thickness can lead to a more satisfying outcome, ensuring your new hardwood floors serve you well for years to come.

Understanding the Difference: 5/8 vs 3/4 Engineered Hardwood

Before delving into the pros and cons of each thickness, let’s first clarify what exactly differentiates 5/8-inch and 3/4-inch engineered hardwood flooring. To put it simply, the difference lies in the overall thickness of the planks. As the name suggests, 5/8-inch engineered hardwood is 5/8 of an inch thick, while 3/4-inch hardwood measures 3/4 of an inch in thickness.

While this seemingly minor distinction might not appear substantial at first glance, it holds significant implications for a variety of factors, including installation, durability, aesthetics, and ultimately, the overall impact on your finished floors.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Thickness:

Installation and Subfloor Considerations

The chosen thickness of your engineered hardwood flooring plays a pivotal role in the installation process. 3/4-inch engineered hardwood planks, due to their greater thickness, are often considered more stable and less prone to flexing. This makes them a preferred choice for homes with uneven subfloors, as they can better bridge minor variations in level. 5/8-inch planks, on the other hand, might require more meticulous preparation of the subfloor or necessitate the use of leveling compounds to ensure a seamless and even installation.

Image: www.kaplanflooring.ca

Durability and Wear Resistance

While engineered hardwood flooring is renowned for its durability compared to solid hardwood, the thickness can influence its resistance to wear and tear. Thicker planks, like those found in 3/4-inch engineered hardwood, generally offer greater durability and can withstand more foot traffic over time. This makes them a more suitable choice for high-traffic areas such as kitchens, hallways, and entryways. 5/8-inch engineered hardwood, while still durable, might exhibit signs of wear and tear slightly faster in high-traffic areas.

Aesthetics and Floor Height

The thickness of your engineered hardwood flooring can also affect the overall aesthetics and height of your floors. 3/4-inch engineered hardwood can create a more substantial and classic look, adding a touch of elegance to any room. However, it might increase the overall floor height, which could pose a challenge in rooms with low ceilings or when transitioning to other floor coverings. 5/8-inch engineered hardwood offers a sleeker and more contemporary look, while maintaining a relatively lower floor height. This can be advantageous in contemporary homes or rooms with lower ceilings, where minimizing the perceived height is essential.

Cost and Availability

Finally, cost and availability are significant factors to consider when choosing between 5/8-inch and 3/4-inch engineered hardwood. Generally, 3/4-inch engineered hardwood is more expensive than 5/8-inch options, primarily due to the increased amount of material used. However, both thicknesses are widely available from a variety of manufacturers and retailers, ensuring you have a range of options to suit your budget and style preferences.

5/8-inch Engineered Hardwood: A Closer Look

5/8-inch engineered hardwood has gained significant traction in recent years, offering a compelling alternative to the traditional 3/4-inch option. Its advantages include:

• Lower Installation Cost: 5/8-inch engineered hardwood typically requires less material than its thicker counterpart, making it a more budget-friendly option. This can be particularly advantageous for larger areas or when considering multiple rooms.
• Reduced Floor Height: The thinner profile of 5/8-inch engineered hardwood can help maintain a more open and spacious feel in rooms with lower ceilings. This is a crucial factor in contemporary homes or when transitioning to other floor coverings.
• Easy Installation: 5/8-inch engineered hardwood is often easier to install, particularly for DIY enthusiasts. Its lighter weight and thinner profile make it easier to handle and maneuver during installation.
• Sleek and Contemporary Style: The lower height of 5/8-inch engineered hardwood can contribute to a more contemporary and minimalist aesthetic, making it a popular choice for modern homes.

However, 5/8-inch engineered hardwood also comes with its drawbacks:

• Less Durable: While durable, 5/8-inch engineered hardwood might not withstand the wear and tear of high-traffic areas as effectively as its 3/4-inch counterpart. This can be a concern for families with children or pets or for areas that experience heavy foot traffic.
• More Prone to Flexing: The thinner profile of 5/8-inch engineered hardwood can make it more susceptible to flexing, particularly on uneven subfloors. This could result in uneven surfaces or creaking noises over time.
• Limited Availability: Some wood species and styles might not be available in 5/8-inch engineered hardwood, which could restrict your design options.

3/4-inch Engineered Hardwood: A Classic Choice

Traditionally considered the standard, 3/4-inch engineered hardwood has consistently offered a balance of durability, stability, and aesthetics. Its benefits include:

• Increased Durability: 3/4-inch engineered hardwood is generally considered more durable than its 5/8-inch counterpart, offering superior resistance to wear and tear in high-traffic areas. This makes it a popular choice for kitchens, hallways, and entryways.
• Enhanced Stability: Its thicker profile contributes to greater stability, making it less prone to flexing and better able to bridge minor variations in subfloor levels.
• Classic and Elegant Style: 3/4-inch engineered hardwood creates a more substantial and classic look, adding a touch of elegance and sophistication to any room. This can be particularly appealing in traditional, formal, or grand homes.
• Wider Variety of Options: 3/4-inch engineered hardwood is generally available in a wider array of wood species, styles, and finishes, offering greater design flexibility.

However, 3/4-inch engineered hardwood also has its drawbacks:

• Higher Installation Cost: 3/4-inch engineered hardwood is generally more expensive than 5/8-inch options, due to the increased amount of material used. This can be a significant consideration, particularly for larger projects or tight budgets.
• Increased Floor Height: 3/4-inch engineered hardwood can raise the overall floor height, which might pose a challenge in rooms with low ceilings or when transitioning to other floor coverings.
• More Difficult Installation: The heavier weight and thicker profile of 3/4-inch engineered hardwood can make installation more challenging, particularly for DIY projects.

5/8 Vs 3/4 Engineered Hardwood Flooring

The Final Decision: Choosing the Right Thickness

Choosing between 5/8-inch and 3/4-inch engineered hardwood is a matter of weighing your priorities and circumstances. If budget, floor height, and ease of installation are your primary concerns, 5/8-inch engineered hardwood can be a viable option. However, if durability, stability, and a classic aesthetic are paramount, 3/4-inch engineered hardwood might be the better choice.

Ultimately, the best decision depends on your unique needs and preferences. Consulting with a professional flooring specialist can provide valuable insights and guidance, helping you select the ideal thickness for your home while ensuring your new hardwood floors are a source of beauty, comfort, and lasting satisfaction for years to come. Remember, while thickness plays a significant role, it’s only one aspect of choosing the right engineered hardwood. Consider exploring different wood species, styles, and finishes to find the perfect match for your vision and lifestyle.